Sticking to the threads title, Paramedic vs RN.
Getting the pay stuff out of the way (not a concern of mine) What do you ladies and gents think about the scope of practice between an Registered Nurse, and a Paramedic?
I've heard a lot, that once you get your ASN, and aquire the NCLEX-RN, you can challenge the NREMT-P. Are the skills between the two really that similiar?
Do you think one may compliment the other? (Being skilled as a Paramedic, at the same time being skilled as a Registered Nurse, Pre-Hospital, and Post Hospital Medical Skills. Or experiences working in both capacities?
I've been hearing a lot about PHRNs (Pre-Hospital Registered Nurse) working with some FDs in and around WA. both RN, and Paramedic certified medical professionals. I've also heard that Flight Medics, and Flight Nurses work side by side in literal sinc. Anyone have any expire on this?
The two professions are totally separate and have verily little in common. The same as a a x-ray tech and RT have in common. The methodologies and philosophies are nothing similar, thus why I am always surprised by those that attempt to judge and compare the two professions.
The scope of practice is as well different due to the job itself is different. Not less or more, just different. So many want to acclaim that nurses require orders to do anything, when in reality so do all of those in EMS. Albeit that most have standing orders disguised as protocols, they still have to have orders alike the RN which most hospitals have in place for the area they work in.
The education of nursing is much more traditional. Alike other formal education routes, they have a standardized curriculum but it is NOT objective based unlike that of EMS. Something the new EMS Standards is attempting to accomplish but will have a hard time, since the majority of EMS Instructors are not educated enough to teach as in developing lesson plans and having a full understanding of adult education. Where as in nursing the minimal to teach RN is a graduate degree to a doctorate, even the LPN instructor requires a BSN to MSN level. A far cry from those that teach EMS where the most requires is a GED and a 39 hour EMS Instructor course.
Nursing of course has been around for decades and they take that role very seriously. I have found nursing also police their profession much better than those within EMS. Sure we can all point poor nurses, but in general and per numbers compare this to the number of poor providers within EMS. Personal behavior such as substance abuse is much more watched and patient complaints is taken much more seriously.... in general much more professional.
Ironically I have yet heard any nurse complain of taking any science courses or witnessed two week nursing classes. Even now the accelerated and on-line type are being scrutinized and many states not allowing them altogether or requiring additional classes, even though that person has passed the RN license. That does not mean that they may practice within a specific state.
Truthfully, I love EMS but I respect nursing. I am beginning to miss nursing. The problems of nursing is that administration takes advantage of the profession. I believe nursing is much harder and wearing than EMS. Yes, in EMS we all have bad days.. difficult patients that are hard to deal with but remember where you dropped them off? The nurse does not just have the one but two or three more just alike them and they will have to provide care for hours not minutes to them.
Paramedics can gain the same respect, money and professionalism if they choose to do so. The problem is that the majority want it without the work and sacrifices. They much rather take a 10 month program without any basic sciences, no academic courses associated with the profession. Then they still whine and complain that they have so much to study; even though the majority of the schools still utilize a one textbook philosophy. How ludicrous!
The skills can be similar but from a total different approach. Suctioning is suctioning, but there is NO reference to prehospital care or even emergency care. In my opinion, nurses should NOT be able to challenge the Paramedic test the curriculum does NOT cover the material needed nor the role or function of the Paramedic. Alike a Paramedic should not be able to challenge the RN test without proper education. There are very few states that recognize PHRN and there is a reason for that. I and some others are developing a RN to Paramedic bridge program. Yes, there are some areas that they will be able obtain credit and challenge but there are areas that they will have to have as much education and skill monitoring as those just entering EMS. I had heard that the NREMT allowed RN to challenge but have since abolished that practice.
You will not find volunteer nursing alike that in EMS. To replace or subsitute the role of a professional nurse. Yes, you will find those that will volunteer their services but to replace the role of a needed professional nurse...no. I have seen nurses raise money to fund a full time nurse or those associated with missionary missions that entered that professionally. Again, the nurse realizes the need of professionalism. Even communities that are rural, small and so forth; you will always find a RN in the hospital, nursing home and they will be compensated for their services. Not to do so, would be an insult not just to the person but the profession.
Anyone entering either one of the professions should do so because that it is the role they want to do. It should be more of a calling than just a job. If you are doing either for just financial reasons, you will not last long and will be unhappy until you quit and move on.
Just remember though, nursing is a diverse profession. Critical care and emergency, as well as flight nursing is just
one area that is nursing. In reality many nurses have the opinion those that work in those areas as we do in EMS about nursing home nurses. The general nursing programs does
NOT prepare or teach any specific areas regarding critical care or emergency. You will NOT ever find a question regarding such on any NCLEX test in regards to critical care/emergency due to it is a speciality. Again, the focus is in general nursing: medical surgical, obstetrics, labor and delivery, psychiatric, community health and pediatrics.
R/r 911