LucidResq
Forum Deputy Chief
- 2,031
- 3
- 0
I know it isn't and I wasn't trying to use that study as evidence that precordial thumps are ineffective or harmful.... just thought it was interesting, since it's been mentioned on here that precordial thumps have caused commotio cordis, this was just an example.Third-degree AVB is not v-fib or asystole. I'll have to look for the studies, but I believe the risks of a precordial thump are relatively low in a non pulse producing rhythm.
I agree, the risks are generally low. I did dig this up though...
Our case highlights a previously undocumented complication following the use of a precordial thump: sternal fracture and osteomyelitis. This necessitated a modification to his coronary artery bypass graft surgery, and he required 6 weeks of intravenous antibiotics.
Ahmar, W., Morley, P., Marasco, S., Chan, W., and Aggarwal, A. 2007. Sternal fracture and osteomyelitis: An unusual complication of a precordial thump. Resuscitation 75:540-542.
Again, just a single case, but interesting (kinda crazy actually).
Other reported complications include deterioration of VT into VF, rate increase in VT, rib fractures, myocardial contusion, etc.... I guess it comes down to a risk-to-benefit thing which is complicated with these patients. Of course, chest compressions have the potential to cause similar types of physical damage... not sure about the effects on VT.
Sclarovsky, S., Kracoff, O. H., and Agmon, J. 1981. Acceleration of ventricular tachycardia induced by a chest thump. Chest 80:596-599.
Sclarovsky, S., Kracoff, O., Arditi, A., Strasberg, B., Zafrir, N., Lewin, R. F., and Agmon, J. 1982. Ventricular tachycardia "pleomorphism" induced by chest thump. Chest 81:97-98.
Befeler B. Mechanical stimulation of the heart. In Befeler B, editor. Selected topics in cardiac arrhythmias. New York: Futura Publishing Co, 1980; 185.