Federal officers delayed, threatened to ‘shoot and arrest’ ambulance crew at Portland ICE facility, report says

Status
Not open for further replies.
If it shows what you believe, then the agency and individuals have options for redress which involve certain procedures (IG complaints, legal action, etc).

It’s worth noting that ICE has a long, pre-Trump record of blatantly ignoring their own policies, and that their current behaviors are making a mockery of any form of legal accountability for their actions. Completely outside our argument, I think there’s a good case to be made that ICE functionally doesn’t care about the laws of the United States at this point, because they consider themselves immune from them.
I'm not disagreeing with aspects of that, but that is a discussion more appropriate for other places than here. Also, while tangentially related to the incident, that history alone is not enough to convict based solely upon that and a claim. Is it enough to question and warrant an investigation? Absolutely.
 
When all this is long over, it will be interesting to see how many leaders in our field will have been quietly removed after they aligned with what is rapidly becoming a Very Unpopular Administration and its local consequences.
 
I'm not disagreeing with aspects of that, but that is a discussion more appropriate for other places than here. Also, while tangentially related to the incident, that history alone is not enough to convict based solely upon that and a claim. Is it enough to question and warrant an investigation? Absolutely.
That’s exactly the thing though: it’s exactly the time for that conversation. If ice really is beyond the law, how are we supposed to interact with them as a profession?

Where do a patient’s rights end and ICE’s begin if they aren’t subject to the laws and policies they have traditionally governed law-enforcement activities?

I mean, what’s to stop them from simply arresting an ems crew that advocates for the patient to go to the hospital instead of alligator Alcatraz? Or from doing a swat raid on an elementary school looking for “illegals”? Or from ripping someone out of the back of an ambulance because they’re a little too brown? There’s no legal obstacles to any of those things, and clearly three of you are completely OK with those things happening…what happens when they do? And before you hit me with allegations of being hyperbolic or exaggerating, remember that this spring, no one thought the ice agents would be shooting pepper ball guns at clergyman praying in front of buildings.
 
Well, clearly, at least three of you in this thread do entertain the thought that an American secret police organization that uses the Constitution as toilet paper is at least acceptable, because “solidarity with law enforcement!”
Your inability to read, interpret, and participate in conversation is truly alarming.
 
Your inability to read, interpret, and participate in conversation is truly alarming.
Not as alarming as your justifications for behaviors like this:

ICE hits and kidnaps American citizen
ICE assaults American citizen

For those of you who don’t feel comfortable seeing your conservative, worldview, shattered, ice agents in the midst of one “law-enforcement operation, did an illegal U-turn and rammed a motorist. They then approach the motorist vehicle with Guns drawn and arrest her, because as we all know, if we’re simply existing in ice is mildly inconvenienced by our actions, they are entitled to threaten us with lethal force and arrest us. Both sides!!!!

But yall keep spending your credit on “both sides” and whataboutism. I mean, surely any agency this professional and respectful would never, ever, ever threaten an ambulance crew with death. That would be a slanderous allegation. What rational law-enforcement officer wouldn’t immediately aim multiple weapons a driver whom they collided with in the midst of an illegal U-turn on a crowded city street? Totally normal behavior right there.
 
Last edited:
That’s exactly the thing though: it’s exactly the time for that conversation. If ice really is beyond the law, how are we supposed to interact with them as a profession?

Where do a patient’s rights end and ICE’s begin if they aren’t subject to the laws and policies they have traditionally governed law-enforcement activities?

I mean, what’s to stop them from simply arresting an ems crew that advocates for the patient to go to the hospital instead of alligator Alcatraz? Or from doing a swat raid on an elementary school looking for “illegals”? Or from ripping someone out of the back of an ambulance because they’re a little too brown? There’s no legal obstacles to any of those things, and clearly three of you are completely OK with those things happening…what happens when they do? And before you hit me with allegations of being hyperbolic or exaggerating, remember that this spring, no one thought the ice agents would be shooting pepper ball guns at clergyman praying in front of buildings.
What part of "more appropriate for other places than here" was I unclear about? Take that discussion to Reddit, X, FB or other social media platforms of your choice.
 
Not as alarming as your justifications for behaviors like this:

ICE hits and kidnaps American citizen
ICE assaults American citizen

For those of you who don’t feel comfortable seeing your conservative, worldview, shattered, ice agents in the midst of one “law-enforcement operation, did an illegal U-turn and rammed a motorist. They then approach the motorist vehicle with Guns drawn and arrest her, because as we all know, if we’re simply existing in ice is mildly inconvenienced by our actions, they are entitled to threaten us with lethal force and arrest us. Both sides!!!!

But yall keep spending your credit on “both sides” and whataboutism. I mean, surely any agency this professional and respectful would never, ever, ever threaten an ambulance crew with death. That would be a slanderous allegation. What rational law-enforcement officer wouldn’t immediately aim multiple weapons a driver whom they collided with in the midst of an illegal U-turn on a crowded city street? Totally normal behavior right there.
I’m not going to participate in your attempts to move the goalposts.
 
along those lines, does bias have an effect on behavior, and should we risk our profession to lend credibility to “law enforcement” engaged in morally, socially and legally-indefensible conduct?
As apposed to all the morally, socially, and legal conduct by EMS?
 
What part of "more appropriate for other places than here" was I unclear about? Take that discussion to Reddit, X, FB or other social media platforms of your choice.
I know, it’s hard to have your opinion challenged when it pertains to EMS and our operations with the secret police. Its ok to discuss what’s not OK. You can overcome your fears, ffemt. You just have to acknowledge that there’s a chance you might be entirely incorrect.
 
I know, it’s hard to have your opinion challenged when it pertains to EMS and our operations with the secret police. Its ok to discuss what’s not OK. You can overcome your fears, ffemt. You just have to acknowledge that there’s a chance you might be entirely incorrect.
Unlike you, I fully realize and accept I may be wrong...I just refuse to let my biases interfere with objectivity.
 
Oh, you mean like deference an trust you’re extending to ICE? I mean, the AMR crew is “unverified”, but you’re eagerly carrying at least a half-pail of water for the dudes shooting clergymen in the head with pepperballs…

I’m going to see myself out of this thread before I get banned, but before I go, a historical backhand.

Back in the 1850s, federally-warranted slave catchers empowered by the Fugitive Slave Act came North, kidnapping hundreds of people. Black people weren’t allowed to testify in their own defense, and it took literal tarring and feathering and assault to dissuade them. In defiance of federal law.

You, ffemt, probably wouldn’t have been on the side of Josiah Chamberlain or Robert Gould Shaw…
Equating LE in 2025 to Slavery in the 1850s is just showing how disconnected you are. Please, read something other that Anarchist Weekly.
 
I’m not going to participate in your attempts to move the goalposts.
Of course, not. That would require you to question Dear Leader. And dear leader should never be questioned. Clearly, the organizational process and oversight that results in these brave ice officers kidnapping the victim of their terrible driving, who happens to be an American citizen, is one that she never get any oversight from anyone because it is our perfect.

And surely no one that would ever ram an innocent motorist, and then abduct them at gunpoint, would ever, ever threaten to execute an EMT for the subtle movement of a truck shifting into park. I’m 100% certain that the ice academy has at least one class about not executing EMS personnel, probably in the same slideshow as the one that says we shouldn’t ram other vehicles off the road without a reason.

Maybe that class just got skipped on that day
 
Equating LE in 2025 to Slavery in the 1850s is just showing how disconnected you are. Please, read something other that Anarchist Weekly.
Law-enforcement was far less powerful in the 1850s, the citizens of Boston famously tarred and feathered several slave catchers. President Buchanan was forced to send federal troops and marines to move an abducted slave back into slavery, the resulting riots cost several lives. Boston actually has a very moving memorial to these men, who are sometimes considered to be the first casualties of the Civil War.
 
Unlike you, I fully realize and accept I may be wrong...I just refuse to let my biases interfere with objectivity.
I just don’t think you’re capable of moving past where you are, which is using objectivity as a shield for your own discomfort and lack of confidence, it taking an actual principled stand.
 
Of course, not. That would require you to question Dear Leader. And dear leader should never be questioned. Clearly, the organizational process and oversight that results in these brave ice officers kidnapping the victim of their terrible driving, who happens to be an American citizen, is one that she never get any oversight from anyone because it is our perfect.

And surely no one that would ever ram an innocent motorist, and then abduct them at gunpoint, would ever, ever threaten to execute an EMT for the subtle movement of a truck shifting into park. I’m 100% certain that the ice academy has at least one class about not executing EMS personnel, probably in the same slideshow as the one that says we shouldn’t ram other vehicles off the road without a reason.

Maybe that class just got skipped on that day
Wow.
 
Would you tolerate one of your crews busting an illegal U-turn, ramming another motorist, threatening them, ripping them out of their vehicle and kidnapping them? Would you tolerate that from your local law-enforcement departments? Do you want that in your community?
 
And that's enough of this one.

I gave two warnings about taking the larger political discussion elsewhere.
 
Every time you post, you remove that level of professionalism you should be acting under. Do you treat LE any different? Would you?
After ice, I think law-enforcement will be extremely fortunate if they are given any respect whatsoever. Departments with any foresight whatsoever will be sprinting away from any cooperation with ice and standing with their communities against the depravity of ice. Remember, local law-enforcement lives in our communities. Torturing their own reputations by assisting with the indefensible is a really shortsighted plan.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top