medicrob to the rescue, didnt see your post until after i posted my last, well said.
Do other states have that different teaching criteria?
This is one of the issues that EMS faces. In one state the EMT-B level is the EMT-IV while in another it is emt-B with IV, and another it is EMT-cc (I think), etc. The national model addressed this by presenting one set of levels for all emergency medical technicians in the US. States are asked to follow suit, however the time frame for the NREMT exams at these levels is around 2014. TN will be one of the states that goes into the initiative early, having announced that we will start licensing individuals at the EMT-Advanced level as early as Fall 2011 for EMT-IV and will begin the EMT-Advanced initial courses after that.
The national model calls for:
Emergency Medical Responder <--- Our now First Responder
EMT <--- Our current EMT-B
EMT-Advanced <--- Our current I/85
Paramedic <--- Our current Paramedic and i/99s who bridge.
South Carolina was allowing EMT-B to intubate at one point. The scope of practice is set by your individual state in adherance with national guidelines
and your individual medical director chooses which skills he wishes to authorize you to use in your service and which ones he is not comfortable with.
EMT-B varies across so many states. At last count, there were 47 different EMT titles.
I think the EMT-Advanced is going to come in handy in rural areas and in areas where services can't justify having paramedics on staff.
As far as TN goes, most of our trucks run: Medic/Medic, Medic/EMT-IV, however a lot of services still have BLS trucks that run EMT-IV/EMT-IV but remember, EMT-IV is technically not a B because this level is trained under the i/85 curriculum. This is why you see differences between lecture hours, clinicals, and scope with EMT-IV and EMT-B. Our current first responders here in TN have the scope of EMT-B, ever since Combitube and PTL were added. We can all argue over scope, etc. As a matter of fact, we do it in nursing all the time. After all, a BSN spends 4 years in school, and 2 years in clinicals in Trauma Centers, Nursing Homes, ICU, CCU, NICU, OB/GYN, ER, Med/Surg, etc, have to take Anatomy & Physiology I and I (full class, not survey), Pathophysiology, Pharmacology, English Composition, Chemistry, Fundamentals of Prof Speaking, etc. We could hold the argument that a paramedic shouldn't be allowed to perform any of their medical skills before having all these courses and all this time in clinicals, but we don't. Every one has their place in the continuation of care. I think a lot of the Paramedics here would change their mind about EMT-B and IV's if they had the chance to ride along with a TN EMT-IV. Once again, please note I am not saying that an EMT-B should be pushing meds like valium, versed, etc. IV Therapy & Med Admin are two different ballgames.