All I am saying is that this guy sounds like a pretty typical paramedic student, and that his approach is probably fostered and even encouraged by his educators.
Bloom's Taxonomy shows us that "remembering" is the most fundamental aspect of the educational process, and that progression up to "understanding" and beyond cannot take place until the foundational phase is complete. The "analyze and evaluate" phases are the highest parts of the pyramid and take lots of time to develop - likely, much more than a few months. So, quite frankly, I don't think this guy's approach is even wrong.
But even if this guy is wrong in his approach, I think telling him that he's going to be a lousy paramedic is pretty harsh and uncalled for. It's also unlikely to help him or the current paramedic educational paradigm. It's not any individual student's fault that paramedic education is so lacking. I'm not sure how a student can rightly be held responsible for an entire paradigm that has existed since before he was probably even born.