I've been told over and over again that attempting to right mainstem the obstruction as a last ditch attempt is an option. I still don't understand it.
One, at that point I'm going to be cutting rather than ****ing around trying to jam the obstruction further into someone's airway.
Two, if the obstruction was above the crichothyroid membrane and now you force is down in line or below it but not into the right mainstem you've signed that patient's death warrant.
Three, unless you plan on leaving the stylet in place and risking potentially catastrophic airway trauma (but I will agree the argument can be made that "at this point does it matter?") a bougie or ETT doesn't seem stiff enough to me to force anything anywhere. The bougie will just curl up and the ETT would just collapse on itself, in my opinion. With that said, rescue breaths "forcing" the obstruction down aren't an option either, to move that obstruction you're going to need a lot of pressure. If there were nowhere else for that pressure to go then MAYBE, but unfortunately our patients have these pesky little things called an esophagus and a stomach for all that pressure to wander its way into rather than moving the obstruction down the airway any further.
Four, and this is a consideration in urban systems and one of the few times I'd advocate just picking them up and driving fast, how far from a hospital and an MD with a glidescope, bronchoscope, tracheostomy kits and all their other toys?
We had a choking recently that was literally 45 seconds, routine, from the level two trauma center. They tried once, were unsuccessful and picked up and boogied to the ER. They were able to relieve the obstruction and obtain ROSC but unfortunately the patient suffered a massive anoxic brain injury. You'd have to be really close but it's worth a thought, especially if you take a look with a laryngoscope and you recognize there's nothing you can do.