Recruiting, While I appreciate your input, I would love to know what your certification level is... how long have you been in EMS?
Without lashing out, and with respect, I would like to reply with these few points.
You wrote; The physical movement of the pt's trunk with each breath would have made the patient scream in pain, any movement would. He did not do this.
First of all, not all patients can be treated "By the book". With that said, the key thing in EMS is that unfortunatly, we are NOT doctors (although I would love to make thier money!!!), therefore, we do not diagnose in the field, we simply treat the symptoms. I am not sure where you practice at, and really don't care, but if you were on this call with us, (which you obviously were not), you would know that our protocols were followed for a reason. If you are not up to par on your medications, here is a run down on pharmacology.
ASA - first line drug for chest pains (after 02 ofcourse)
Nitro - Nitro is given to relieve chest pains, providing that we have an IV started and the B/P is above 90 systalic.
Morphine - Chest pains, and pain management in general
It was a 25 - 35 min. transport from the best of my recolection. I can tell you from personal experience, not from the book, and this is what they don't teach you in class, Gall Bladder attacks, weather or not it is ruptured, however mine did rupture, can mimic a cardiac event. There is not always tenderness present in the RUQ, I too did not have that. The cardiac protocols were gone through for process of elimination. It did not hurt him to take an ASA, nitro did not hurt him, but it did not help him. This varified that there was no cardiac event going on. Morphine was used for pain management... if you were there, you would understand that something had to be done to help him tolorate the pain. All of the above treatment is the plan of action set up by our OMD to rule out a cardiac event. We don't have to call in for anything, although sometimes it helps us feel better to get the go ahead from the ER doc on drug choices. All of our drugs are on standing orders. The only reason we usually call in is to give report. By the way, You said that the cardiac event could have been ruled out at the scene... I AM ALS, and I don't claim to be a doctor!!!! I had another ALS provider with me also.
We are a very agressive squad, and region for that matter. Our OMD wants us to be agressive. Alot of the treatment differences come from protocol differences... and EXPERIENCE IN THE FIELD. Listen to your patient, evaluate your symptoms, treat the symptoms... don't try to play doc! It is impossable to compleatly diagnose in the field!!!!!!!!!!!! Never reasure the patient in the field... this is outlined in the 2003 Mosby edition of "The Basic EMT". We can try to keep them calm, but it is discouraged these days to reasure. This gives the patient false hope.
It is ok to work out a scenario, but do not try this "I know all and you know nothing attitued". You will not make many friends here. You don't have to try to impress anyone here. We all get together on here, we don't bash eachother, or try to make people look or sound stupid, we get together to discuss our experiences in the field and talk out calls with other providers. You might want to consider reading other entries before you post another "know it all" reply. Try learning more about what you are talking about before you try to quote treatment plans in the way that you did on here. With respect! I hope others will agree with me.