I'd say based on the given information you are right on. Resp. rate above 30 definately qualifies as inadequate respirations and warrants a BVM. However, we all need to remember to be careful to treat the patient and not the machine. Even if the SpO2 reads 84%, look at the patient, their color, general appearance, etc. I've had perfectly healthy, non resp-distress pt's who's sat has been read on the maching as 80%....not likely.