It's funny reading all the different opinions on this topic, as it reminds me of listening to politicians and how they always take the side of their party. We all think the system we work in is the best. I haven't read any posts from someone saying I work in Fire Based and it sucks, or vice versa with privates? I'm not bashing anyone, hell... I'm guilty of it myself. It's just funny how we all spend so much time trying to make our points and convince others to agree with our contention when in the end we are all loyal to the systems we work in.
I was working at a FD when I discovered something was wrong. I then went to another FD where it was even worse. During my third FD employment (whch actually valued EMS), I became of the mind that despite carrying the party line for years, something needed to change.
I have since encountered other former firefighters (most of whom are now physicians, and a handful serving in medical only capacities both in hospital and teaching organizations) that noticed the same thing.
I have even worked private and 3rd service EMS. I am not supporting one system over another. I am striving for the best system, who provides it is inconsequential. But in order to get there it will take certain things. Which will need to be done in a certain order.
In my experience and research, the fire service is the largest opponent of change. Which is not only for the better, but without it puts both fire and EMS at the risk of becomming obsolete. (happy to discuss specifics anytime)
I support any agency wishing to advance the cause. The trouble is the fire service seems to be led by a bunch of people who don't want to admit change must happen. They spout propaganda and like history has always done, eventually the truth will come out.
Some of the fire services most distinguished leaders are driving it to a cliff with EMS. I hope the rank and file will not go over like lemmings, but it is in their hands, not mine. I can only point out the cliff and how to change course.
If you deny there are problems, whether fire based, private, public, 3rd service, whatever; it is like denying the Americans are invading Iraq as our tanks roll through the streets. (you remember that Iraqi information minister under Sadaam doing that!)
There are countless examples in literature as well.
I suspect I get through to some and not others. But I will continue to try.
Last edited by a moderator: