Recovery Position

CPRinProgress

Forum Lieutenant
116
0
16
I work as a lifeguard but I am also an EMT. We were training where I work as a lifeguard and my supervisor asked me a question out of a lifeguarding book. Here is the question.

You are working as a lifeguard and you walk into a maintenance room and find a maintenance worker laying supine on the ground unresponsive but breathing. He is laying at the base of a ladder. You must leave to get help. What should you do?

The two answers I was between were

Leave him how he is and get help

Place him in recovery position and then leave to get help.

I picked to leave him how he was but my supervisor said the right answer was to place him in recovery to keep his airway open. I thought that since he was laying at the bottom of the ladder, he may have a spinal injury and since he was breathing on his own, I thought it would be best to leave him and then come back and administer care. Am I right in my thinking or am I wrong?
 

UnkiEMT

Forum Truck Monkey
Premium Member
326
5
18
I'd side with you, the fact that he's at the base of the ladder at least raises the possibility of a trauma MOI, and thus I wouldn't go moving him about.

I was going to say that it's a matter of scope and training, that lifeguards don't deal with spinal precautions and thus wouldn't be tested on it, but back when I did my lifeguard, we totally covered what to do if someone dives headlong into the bottom, did you?

Of course, the real answer is grab your cell phone and call 911, get a truck rolling for a man down, put the operator on speakerphone and do a rapid assessment to see if you can give them a bit better information.
 
OP
OP
C

CPRinProgress

Forum Lieutenant
116
0
16
Yes. We are only trained to deal with spibak injuries that occur in the water and they teach us how to do a standing takedown. We do not, however, learn how to log roll if someone is laying on the ground. We are supposed to call EMS and let them handle that. I figured it wasa scope of practice thing I was just surprised that they would put the whole thing with the ladder in if they didn't seem to care about the possible trauma.
 

rmabrey

Forum Asst. Chief
854
1
18
You're supervisors logic is this: ABC C-spine

My phone is dyingg or id go into more detail but someone will be along to do it.
 
OP
OP
C

CPRinProgress

Forum Lieutenant
116
0
16
You're supervisors logic is this: ABC C-spine

My phone is dyingg or id go into more detail but someone will be along to do it.

I understand that airway trumps spinal but the question stated they were breathing so the airway is open. I guess it is possible for it to close but in the time it would take to leave and tell someone to call 911 and return, that doesn't seem like it would affect the pt.
 

teedubbyaw

Forum Deputy Chief
1,036
461
83
That's a pretty silly question. Is he not maintaining his airway? Snoring resps? Gurgling? Then leave it be for the 30 seconds it takes you to get help.
 

Ewok Jerky

PA-C
1,401
738
113
Can't you put someone in recovery position with their arm supporting their head thus "maintaining" c spine? Modified recovery or lateral recumbant or something?

As for test questions ALWAYS remember A>B>C, always always always, even when it don't make sense.
 
OP
OP
C

CPRinProgress

Forum Lieutenant
116
0
16
That's a pretty silly question. Is he not maintaining his airway? Snoring resps? Gurgling? Then leave it be for the 30 seconds it takes you to get help.

It is from a LG book so it didn't go into that much detail but I'm assuming when they say he is breathing, they mean adequately.
 

OnceAnEMT

Forum Asst. Chief
734
170
43
As for test questions ALWAYS remember A>B>C, always always always, even when it don't make sense.

I've actually been hearing a lot of C(spine)>A>B>C lately, as C-spine positioning literally makes or breaks your airway.

My cell phone would be on the deck with 911 dialing on speaker.
 
OP
OP
C

CPRinProgress

Forum Lieutenant
116
0
16
Can't you put someone in recovery position with their arm supporting their head thus "maintaining" c spine? Modified recovery or lateral recumbant or something?

As for test questions ALWAYS remember A>B>C, always always always, even when it don't make sense.

I'm not sure about the recovery position that maintains c spine. My point is that if they are maintaining their own airway at that time, then why compromise cspine unnecessarily.
 

mycrofft

Still crazy but elsewhere
11,322
48
48
HAINES position.*

If someone can't get out of supine position (unconscious, spine board, paralyzed) you need to protect their airway.

*I am seeing two versions. The one I teach at ARC has both knees bent on completion. All the non ARC stuff I see has only the upper leg bent. The deal is holed the head while turning from supine to semi-prpone and wind up with the head held in approximate alignment with shoulders on top of the lower humerus.
Here's one:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WUHSBsxNJ-Y
 
Last edited by a moderator:
OP
OP
C

CPRinProgress

Forum Lieutenant
116
0
16
HAINES position.

If someone can't get out of supine position (unconscious, spine board, paralyzed) you need to protect their airway.

Thank you mycrofft. I don't remember that from EMT class. The question was after I had taken my recert for LG but I didn't take the first aid portion of the class because they let me skip it since I am an EMT. I guess I should have attended it. Haha
 

mycrofft

Still crazy but elsewhere
11,322
48
48
I edited the comment as you posted.
It is basic ARC first aid. ;)
 

mycrofft

Still crazy but elsewhere
11,322
48
48
Last edited by a moderator:

cprted

Forum Captain
389
183
43
What if your patient has a head injury and starts vomiting while you're gone?

Life over limb. Being able to breath is far more important than being able to feel your toes. Roll to recovery if you have to leave.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

cprted

Forum Captain
389
183
43
OK. Well thank you for the quick reply. I thought it was weird that the question would include the part of the ladder if they just expected lifeguards to disregard the possible spinal injury.
You're not "disregarding" the possibility of spinal injuries. You're expected to consider spinal injury and prioritize appropriately.
 

mycrofft

Still crazy but elsewhere
11,322
48
48
zsstop and read all replies. I'll stop editing mine! ;)
 

Christopher

Forum Deputy Chief
1,344
74
48
I work as a lifeguard but I am also an EMT. We were training where I work as a lifeguard and my supervisor asked me a question out of a lifeguarding book. Here is the question.

You are working as a lifeguard and you walk into a maintenance room and find a maintenance worker laying supine on the ground unresponsive but breathing. He is laying at the base of a ladder. You must leave to get help. What should you do?

The two answers I was between were

Leave him how he is and get help

Place him in recovery position and then leave to get help.

I picked to leave him how he was but my supervisor said the right answer was to place him in recovery to keep his airway open. I thought that since he was laying at the bottom of the ladder, he may have a spinal injury and since he was breathing on his own, I thought it would be best to leave him and then come back and administer care. Am I right in my thinking or am I wrong?

The recovery position, or HAINES position, is fine for any patient. Lateral "immobilization" is common in places that actually read good and stuff. Supine is unnatural, impairs pulmonary function, and opens your patient up to the risk of aspiration.

We've got some sick fetish whereby we lay everybody down supine who is sick or injured...can I get some head elevation please? Won't anybody think of the side sleepers?!
 
Top